Over 80% of donors say they're more motivated to give when the impact is local. [1] They want to see the effect of their donations close to home. They want to know where their money goes and who it helps.
And yet, billions of dollars sit parked, unspent, unmatched, and unconnected, because people simply can't find the right place to give. [2]
It presents as a generosity problem, but it could be more about discovery than dollars. And it might be the biggest quiet story in the nonprofit world.
People Want to Give Locally
According to a 2025 survey of 512 donors by the consultancy Brand Federation, local impact outweighs national causes when it comes to motivating donors. [1] Fidelity Charitable found that four out of five of its donor-advised fund accounts in 30 metro areas gave to at least one nonprofit in their own city. [3]
This isn't surprising when you think about it. People drive past the park that needs a new playground. They see the food pantry in their town running low. They know the volunteer fire department that's short on equipment. Local giving feels tangible in a way that writing a check to a national organization never quite does.
And that instinct runs even deeper than geography. A 2024 CAF America survey, cited by RallyUp, found that 72% of donors feel strongly about a specific cause. [4] In my experience, people would rather give to problems they emotionally recognize than to large organizations telling them where the money should go. Specificity wins. Personal relevance wins. The closer the cause is to someone's daily life, the more likely they are to feel better about opening their wallet.
So Where Does the Money Go? Nowhere.
If the desire to give locally is this strong, you'd expect the infrastructure to match it. It doesn't.
When Vanguard Charitable, one of the largest sponsors of donor-advised funds in the U.S., [5] surveyed its donors early in the pandemic, 79% said they wanted more resources to give to COVID-19 relief in their own communities. In other words, they wanted to give locally and didn't know where. [6] [7]
Think about that for a moment. Nearly 8 in 10 donors with money already set aside for charity wanted more help finding local places to give it.
Vanguard's response was to build an entire product, the Nonprofit Aid Visualizer (NAVi), specifically designed to surface small, community-level organizations that donors couldn't find on their own. [7] [8] That tool was built for a crisis, but the problem it exposed never went away: for most people, finding a good local nonprofit still takes far more digging than it should.
Meanwhile, more than $327 billion now sits in donor-advised funds. [2] These are accounts where money has been set aside for charitable purposes but hasn't been distributed yet. Some of that delay is strategic. But some of it is simply inertia: people have the money earmarked, but they haven't found the right organization to send it to.
And here's the feedback loop that makes it worse: 83% of donors say they need to see clear impact or outcomes to keep supporting an organization. [1] Small local nonprofits, the ones doing the most visible community-level work, are often the least equipped to market themselves. Most run on shoestring budgets, with volunteers or a small staff doing the work of several roles at once. [9] They don't have communications departments or content strategies to share the terrific work they're doing with the public consistently. The organizations most likely to deliver the tangible impact donors crave are the hardest to find.
What This Looks Like on Long Island
Long Island is a perfect case study for this gap. Nassau and Suffolk counties are home to thousands of nonprofits (New York's State Comptroller's office counted 3,204 nonprofit establishments on Long Island): land trusts, conservation groups, "Friends of" organizations tied to state parks and preserves, food banks, youth programs, community arts organizations, veteran services, animal welfare, and more. [10]
Many of them are doing extraordinary work. Most of them are invisible outside their own mailing lists.
If you wanted to find every public event, volunteer opportunity, or open position at a Long Island nonprofit this weekend, there's no single place to look. You'd have to check dozens of individual websites, follow scattered social media accounts, or hope that someone forwarded you the right email. For an area with this much nonprofit activity, the lack of a central, curated resource is remarkable.
The result is predictable: good organizations stay small, worthy causes go unfunded, and people who genuinely want to help don't know how to start. The generosity is there. The connection is missing.
Closing the Gap
The good news is that this is a solvable problem. It doesn't require more money or more nonprofits. It requires better connective tissue. A way to surface the work that's already happening so people can find it and show up.
That's why we started Proof Positive Network — to give Long Island's nonprofits and community organizations the visibility they deserve. These organizations are already doing the work. They're restoring trails, running food drives, mentoring kids, protecting coastlines and animals, making art accessible, and much more. They just need more people to know about it. More people to come enjoy it.
If you want to find them — their events, their volunteer days, their open positions — Proof Positive Network puts it all in one place. Use it to explore the nonprofits near you that are making a real local impact and let's find something good to do together.
Last updated November 18, 2026.
🥫 For what giving feels like up close, read The Distance Between Donating a Can of Food and Standing Next to the Person Who Needs It.
And if you're not sure what a land trust or "Friends of" group does, start with What's the Difference Between Parks, Preserves, Land Trusts & Conservation Easements.
Local Giving FAQs
Why don't more people give to local nonprofits?
Many want to, but small local nonprofits can be hard to find. Most run on small budgets, and few have anyone whose job is to tell their story. [9]
What is a donor-advised fund?
It's a charitable account where someone sets money aside for giving, then recommends grants to nonprofits over time. Donor-advised funds held more than $327 billion in FY2024. [2]
How can I find nonprofits to support on Long Island?
Proof Positive Network lists Long Island nonprofit events, volunteer opportunities and jobs in one place. Start with this week's volunteer opportunities or events.
Sources
1. NonProfit PRO — Local Impact Outweighs National Causes When It Comes to Nonprofit Fundraising (Brand Federation "Voices for Good" survey, November 2025)
2. DAF Research Collaborative — Annual DAF Report 2025 (FY2024 data)
3. Fidelity Charitable — 2025 Geography of Giving (2024 data)
4. RallyUp — Donor Behavior Statistics (January 2026), citing CAF America's 2024 Spirit of Giving survey
5. Chronicle of Philanthropy — Donor-advised fund grant making grew slower in 2021 (March 2022)
6. Candid — New tool makes giving during a pandemic easier, by Vanguard Charitable (October 2020)
7. Giving Compass — Nonprofit Aid Visualizer (NAVi) donor tool (October 2020)
8. Worth — Rebecca Moffett on Vanguard Charitable's impact (May 2022)
9. National Council of Nonprofits — Nonprofit Impact Matters
10. Health & Welfare Council of Long Island, republishing Newsday — Long Island nonprofits and the State Comptroller's report (January 2025)



















